Mustad Short Shank Fly Tying Hook Size 18 Fly Fishing – Pack of 100
# **Kylebooker Mustad Short Shank Fly Tying Hook Size 18 Fly Fishing – Pack of 100: A Comprehensive Review on Value for Money**
Fly fishing enthusiasts know that the quality of hooks can make or break a successful fishing trip. One of the popular choices among anglers is the **Kylebooker Mustad Short Shank Fly Tying Hook in Size 18**, sold in a pack of 100. But how does this product stack up in terms of affordability, durability, and performance? In this review, we will analyze its **cost-effectiveness** and whether it’s worth adding to your fly-tying arsenal.
## **1. Price vs. Quantity: A Great Deal for Bulk Buyers**
One of the biggest selling points of this hook is its **quantity**. A pack of 100 hooks is ideal for serious fly tyers who go through hooks quickly. Compared to smaller packs (e.g., 25 or 50 hooks), buying in bulk significantly reduces the **cost per hook**, making it a budget-friendly option.
When compared to premium brands like **Tiemco or Gamakatsu**, the **Kylebooker Mustad hooks** are considerably cheaper while still maintaining decent quality. If you’re an angler who ties dozens of flies per season, this pack offers **excellent value for money**.
## **2. Hook Quality & Performance**
Mustad is a well-known brand in the fishing industry, and their hooks are generally reliable. The **short shank design** of these hooks is particularly useful for:
– **Smaller fly patterns** (midges, nymphs, and dry flies)
– **Better hook penetration** due to the compact shape
– **Reduced weight**, making them ideal for delicate presentations
The **Size 18** is versatile enough for trout, panfish, and even small bass flies. The **sharpness out of the package** is good, though some users may prefer to hone them further for ultra-fine presentations.
However, one minor drawback is that these hooks are **not chemically sharpened** like some high-end models. This means they may require occasional sharpening after prolonged use. Still, for the price, they perform admirably.
## **3. Durability & Corrosion Resistance**
The **Mustad steel construction** ensures decent durability, but these hooks are **not stainless steel**. If you frequently fish in **saltwater or highly acidic environments**, they may rust over time unless properly dried and stored.
That said, for **freshwater fly fishing**, they hold up well. A light coating of oil or a rust inhibitor can extend their lifespan. Considering the low cost, replacing them periodically isn’t a major concern.
## **4. Comparison with Competing Brands**
To assess **true value**, let’s compare the Kylebooker Mustad hooks with alternatives:
| **Feature** | **Kylebooker Mustad (Size 18, 100pk)** | **Tiemco 100 (Size 18, 25pk)** | **Gamakatsu C12 (Size 18, 25pk)** |
|————————|——————————–|—————————–|—————————–|
| **Price per Hook** | **$0.08 – $0.12** (bulk discount) | **$0.25 – $0.40** | **$0.30 – $0.50** |
| **Sharpness** | Good (may need sharpening) | Excellent (chemically sharpened) | Excellent (laser-sharp) |
| **Corrosion Resistance** | Moderate (needs care) | High (better coatings) | High (stainless options) |
| **Best For** | Budget-conscious anglers, bulk tying | Professional fly tyers | Saltwater & premium flies |
As seen, the **Kylebooker Mustad hooks** are the most economical choice, making them perfect for **beginners or those who lose flies frequently**.
## **5. Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?**
**Pros:**
✔ **Affordable bulk pricing** – great for frequent fly tyers
✔ **Decent sharpness & short shank design** – good for small flies
✔ **Trusted Mustad quality** – reliable for freshwater fishing
**Cons:**
✖ **Not chemically sharpened** – may require maintenance
✖ **Average corrosion resistance** – not ideal for saltwater
### **Conclusion: A Solid Budget Option**
If you’re looking for a **cost-effective hook for freshwater fly tying**, the **Kylebooker Mustad Short Shank Size 18 (Pack of 100)** is a **fantastic deal**. While they may not match the ultra-premium sharpness of Tiemco or Gamakatsu, their **price-to-performance ratio** makes them a **smart buy for most anglers**.
For **beginners, guides, or those who lose flies often**, this pack ensures you’re never short on hooks without breaking the bank. **Highly recommended for value-conscious fly fishers!**
Would you try these hooks? Let us know your thoughts in the comments! 🎣